Birth Trauma Doesn’t Disappear Just Because You Heard ‘Healthy Baby, Healthy Mom
- Eva Monhaut-Jenkins
- Aug 25
- 3 min read
She lays in the hospital bed, hollow-eyed and silent, while everyone around her congratulates her on a “beautiful birth.” They mean well. But she doesn’t feel seen. She doesn't feel celebrated. Instead, she hears it — the phrase that lands like a slap:
“Well, at least the baby is healthy.”
This sentence is often delivered like a gift — a silver lining, a bow to wrap around a chaotic, traumatic, or disrespectful birth. But in reality, it's a phrase that has silenced countless birthing people, dismissing their pain, their voice, and their story.
Let’s be clear: Yes, a healthy baby matters. But when that outcome is used to minimize what someone endured to get there, it becomes a weapon — not a comfort.
The Problem with “Healthy Baby, Healthy Mom”
This phrase often shows up after something went wrong:
After a birthing person’s “no” was ignored.
After a traumatic cesarean they didn’t consent to.
After aggressive or coercive induction tactics.
After their concerns were brushed off with clinical detachment
And then, in the aftermath, when they dare to speak about what hurt — what violated — they’re met with five words that tell them to be quiet. Grateful. Compliant.
But trauma can coexist with gratitude. You can love your baby and still mourn the way you were treated.
Birth Trauma Is Real — And It Leaves a Mark
According to the Listening to Mothers survey, 1 in 6 people describe their births as traumatic — and many of those respondents had what providers would call “successful” outcomes.
Research published by Beck et al. (2018) shows that birth trauma is strongly linked to postpartum depression, anxiety, and even PTSD, especially when birthing people felt:
Ignored or powerless
Disrespected
Mistreated or coerced
Like things were done to them, not with them
The World Health Organization even recognizes respectful maternity care as a key component of health. They state that quality care includes preserving dignity, privacy, informed choice, and continuous support.
In other words: the way you were treated matters. And your trauma doesn’t get erased by a heartbeat.
Why This Phrase Protects the System, Not the Parent
Too often, “Healthy baby, healthy mom” is used by providers or institutions as emotional damage control. It’s a subtle way of saying, “Don’t complain. We did our job.” But what about your job — the job of birthing, laboring, navigating fear, enduring hours (sometimes days) of interventions?
You’re not just a vessel. You are a human being, and you deserve to be respected, informed, and included every step of the way.
Let’s Redefine a Healthy Birth
A truly healthy birth includes:
Informed consent and real-time communication
Supportive, trauma-informed care
Space for emotions — even the hard ones
A birthing person who feels powerful and seen
You are allowed to process your experience. You are allowed to be angry, hurt, confused — even if the medical chart says “all good.”
What Now? Reclaim Your Story
If you’ve heard this phrase and felt dismissed, I want you to know: You’re not being dramatic. You’re being honest. And you deserve better than silence wrapped in a smile.
As a birth doula and advocate, I support clients in navigating their care with clarity, power, and deep self-trust — before, during, and after birth. Because birth doesn’t just happen to you. You get to co-create it.
If this post resonated with you, share it with someone who needs to hear it — or reach out. Let’s talk about what your empowered birth could look like.
Comments